Turns out A Dead Japanese Beetle IS a Good Japanese Beetle!
Helpful Products from Gardens Alive!
Super-Light Insect Barrier
Pyola® Insect Spray
Surround at Home® Crop Protectant
---Carol in Princeton, New Jersey
A: Ha! Good old New Jersey Justice. Maybe they should change their motto from "The Garden State" to "We know how to make problems go away."
Anyway, Carol's technique is an adaption of the old 'bug juice' trick that many farmers and organic gardeners used to rely on. At least as far back as the sixties—and maybe even earlier—growers would capture a number of the pest insects that were attacking a certain crop, put them into an old blender with about a pint of water, whiz it up, strain it, put the strained liquid into a sprayer and soak the plants under attack with the 'juice' in the hope that incoming live insects would smell what had happened to their relatives and retreat.
The tactic has been especially popular against Japanese beetles—perhaps because they're easy to catch, even without traps. During a severe invasion, a pair of gardeners working together can easily knock a hundred or so into a bucket of soapy water in a few minutes. (The soap coats them and prevents them from flying away. And it's actually good to have a little soap in the final mix as it helps the 'beetle juice' stick to the leaves.)
Oh--and if you see Japanese beetle type damage (those distinctively 'lacey' leaves) but see no beetles during the day, you may have their nocturnal cousins, the Oriental beetle visiting your plants in the evening. Here's an specifically about this equally destructive member of the scarab beetle family.
But I think Carol's idea is an improvement. I remember how stinky those beetle trap bags would get if you left them up too long, and with her additional 'New Jersey pounding', the scent will be much fiercer than if the beetles were diluted with water. Besides, what gardener wouldn't like to pound a bag of the beetles that had just been defoliating their plants?
And it's great to see that Carol is using her Japanese beetle traps effectively. The devices can work against gardeners who put the traps right near vulnerable plants by attracting many more beetles to the plantings than would otherwise show up. But the traps can be protective when placed at the outskirts of your garden, to intercept incoming Japanese beetles before they can "smell the roses" (or grapevines, or cherry trees, or raspberries….).
That's right—Japanese beetles do sometimes attack my wife's precious raspberries. (Her love of which convinced me to become a gardener way back when!) This year, I've only seen—and successfully squished—maybe a dozen so far. And they've only been on the leaves, not the fruit. But if I had bigger problems (like a lot of my listeners are reporting), I just might hang some traps on the outskirts of my property and 'borrow' Carol's idea.
Too squeamish for the "Garden State Solution"? Spray the beetles with a light horticultural oil or insecticidal soap. Or, if you have an old blender, have a helper hold a bucket of soapy water underneath while you reach in towards them (the beetles have developed a great 'drop and roll' maneuver that you have to learn to use against them) and use your catch to try the 'bug juice' solution. (Yes, it's still kind of gross, but you don't have to pound them this way.)
And if you're in a beetle-infested area where it's been constantly wet (as has been the case in the Mid-Atlantic States this year), I would treat the lawn with milky spore disease over the next two months or release beneficial nematodes into the soil when it's nice and wet on a warm evening.
Female Japanese beetles love to lay their eggs in wet lawns, and sometimes that turf is going to be constantly wet even when the lawn owner is personally watering wisely. Beneficial nematodes and milky spore are safe ways to eliminate the grubs that would have emerged as rose-ravaging beetles next year—after feasting on the roots of your poor lawn this fall.
Just choose nematodes or milky spore; don't use both at once. And don't use chemical grub killer—it's toxic to you, your pets and wildlife and it would negate the effectiveness of the safe methods.