Save $25 When You Buy $50 Or More! July Sale Ends Soon!

Three Questions about Compost: Are Ants Good or Bad? Can You Compost Shrimp Shells? & Can We Eat our Pile?

Question. Last summer I noticed lots of small brown ants in my compost bin. This year, the bin is covered in them. I moved the bin and found clumps of larvae throughout the unfinished compost. I'm not sure if this is good or bad; can you shed some light?

---Tammy in Dubuque, Iowa

Answer. Up until now, I thought I had sublet my compost piles to every type of outdoor creature; but I never had ants move in. Now, ants are a mixed bag in the garden; they aerate the soil and eat a lot of insect pests while those pests are still in their more-vulnerable larval stage. But ants also protect aphids from predators so that they can 'farm' the aphids for the sweet honeydew they excrete. (Aphids infesting roses are often the 'dairy cattle' of a nearby ant colony.)

Ants are probably always visiting the interiors of compost piles for a quick look-see; and it sounds like a Queen may have chosen your pile as a nice place to raise a few thousand young. You probably evicted them when you moved the pile, and the ants shouldn't have hurt the actual compost; ants are one of the many types of creatures who break down organic matter in such situations. But they can deliver an annoying little formic acid bite if they get on you, and you wouldn't want to deliberately introduce a bajillion ants into your garden, if only for fear of their aphid farming habit.

You might want to deter them by segregating your ant-attracting green matter like kitchen waste in future piles. An indoor worm bin is the ideal place to recycle such garbage, especially in Northern areas like Iowa, where the long cold winters create a short outdoor composting season. And the specialized worms in an indoor bin make much higher quality compost out of kitchen waste than even the best outdoor pile can achieve.

Shredded leaves alone, or shredded leaves mixed with a high-nitrogen source of green material like coffee grounds or barnyard manure, will make excellent compost outdoors; and I don't think those ingredients would be very ant-attractive.

Question. If fish fertilizers are OK, is there any reason not to put shrimp shells in my compost pile?
    ---Mary in Havertown, PA (just outside of Philadelphia)
Answer. Well, fish and crustaceans like shrimp aren't even remotely related, Mary; they are entirely different types of creatures. But shellfish shells—shrimp, crab and lobster—are chock full of nitrogen, important trace elements, and some highly specialized nutrients (like chitin) that plants enjoy tremendously. So, although your basic allusion is incorrect, shellfish shells are an even better potential plant food than fish waste.

BUT (did all of you hear that 'but' coming?) adding that kind of odiferously attractive material to an open outdoor compost pile is certain to attract vermin of all sizes, from mice and rats to raccoons, who would think they had stumbled onto a pot of gold. Fish and shellfish waste is composted and processed into fertilizer by professionals, but a homeowner who tries it in their backyard will be begging for trouble; potentially dangerous disease-carrying trouble.

You could get one of those free-standing sealed bins made of recycled black plastic, line the bottom with hardware cloth of a small enough mesh to exclude mice, and mix a small amount of pulverized shells in with a huge amount of shredded fall leaves; the nitrogen in the shells would help things cook down quickly, and the resulting compost would be of very high quality. But it's virtually certain that vermin would be unable to resist the smell and would start chewing away at the plastic. A compost tumbler whose body is made of metal would probably be better; malicious mammals couldn't chew their way in.